Your guide to classical music online
Username
Password
Remember Me
Review by: Jed Distler
As a daily blogger for the 18th International Chopin Competition in Warsaw, I was fascinated by one particular contestant, whose impetuous and colorful virtuosity harked back to such capricious interpreters as Shura Cherkassky and Georges Cziffra. To be honest, I didn’t think the jury would take Bruce Liu’s garishly detailed pianism seriously: after all, respectable modern day Chopin players aren’t supposed to reverse dynamics and alter accents, or pull more inner voices out of the hat in one hour than Josef Hofmann did in his entire career. Yet the jury gave Liu first prize, and awarded the Silver and Bronze Medals to similarly individual souls.
All of the selections on this disc stem from Liu’s live, unedited competition performances. Liu’s awesomely effortless virtuosity consistently oozes charisma and insouciance. His Fourth Scherzo’s supple rhythmic spring is right up there with the young Ashkenazy’s staggering live 1955 Chopin Competition performance and Horowitz’s legendary 1936 shellac recording. The Grande Polonaise matches Hofmann’s litheness and rhythmic élan note for note. The Mazurkas evoke Ignaz Friedman’s timing and accentuation, minus the old master’s added octaves and filled in chords. Some of the C-sharp minor Nocturne’s rhetorical gestures border on fey, while the two Etude performances impress more for their polish than their daring.
During the competition I heard comparably detailed yet more substantial Op. 42 renditions from finalists Aimi Kobayashi and Alexander Gadjiev. However, Liu’s gifts reached positively transcendental heights in the “La ci darem” Variations. No other recording of this admittedly flashy and fluffy piece comes close to matching Liu’s nuanced bravura and scintillation. It remains to be seen if the scope of Liu’s gifts ranges beyond showpieces. Then again, how often do you hear such a thoroughly entertaining Chopin recital?
Between 2009 and 2019 Dmitri Alexeev recorded all of Scriabin’s solo piano works for Brilliant Cla... Continue Reading
The Bottom Line: Hearing these vibrant, shapely performances after a pause of a few decades, and a w... Continue Reading
Carlo Maria Giulini had a remarkable career. Not known for his performances of the German standard r... Continue Reading
View Classics Today Insider Archives »
The ten best recordings of 2021 represent an eclectic mix of new recordings and boxed set reissues. Regarding the former, the emphasis for the most part is on interesting or unusual repertoire--the ki... Continue Reading
Shortly after I heard and reviewed Amici e Rivali, a CD devoted to duets by Rossini sung by tenors Michael Spyres and Lawrence Brownlee, I happened upon a video from a European opera house in which Sp... Continue Reading
Theeeyyyyrrre Back! After some strangely wayward recordings of Beethoven's Ninth and Tchaikovsky Fourth, Manfred Honeck is back on form in this new release of Brahms' Fourth Symphony, demonstrating on... Continue Reading
As a daily blogger for the 18th International Chopin Competition in Warsaw, I was fascinated by one particular contestant, whose impetuous and colorful virtuosity harked back to such capricious interp... Continue Reading
Naxos has bundled the five individual CDs in its Leroy Anderson cycle in a slipcase. If you missed any or all of these volumes, several of which were reviewed here (see reviews archive), take advantag... Continue Reading
Please allow me to present ALDA, The Avoid Like Death Awards. These are sort of the evil twin to The Keep On Listening Awards (KOLA), and represent the classical music industry at its most senseless, ... Continue Reading
Exclusive music reviews and news, created specifically for classical music listeners, from the serious collector to the inquisitive newcomer. This is not a fancy, high-gloss “e-zine,” but rather a simple, straightforward newsletter-style section of our website designed for ease of reading and packing the maximum amount of useful information into each issue.
©1999 - 2015 Classics Today All Rights Reserved - Website by FirstTracks Marketing
Comments
0 comment